Why Women Kill, the darkly comedic anthology series created by Marc Cherry, captivated audiences with its unique storytelling and stylish portrayal of marital infidelity across different decades. The show debuted in August 2019 on CBS All Access, which later became Paramount+. After two successful seasons, fans were eagerly anticipating a third season, especially since Paramount+ had already renewed it. However, in a surprising turn of events, the network abruptly canceled the series, leaving fans shocked and searching for answers.
The first season of *Why Women Kill* stood out for its innovative narrative, weaving together the lives of three women from different timelines—1963, 1984, and 2019—all living in the same house and grappling with infidelity in their marriages. Played by Ginnifer Goodwin, Lucy Liu, and Kirby Howell-Baptiste, these women, despite the decades separating them, found themselves on parallel paths of betrayal, heartbreak, and ultimately, murder.
The series explored the dark undercurrents of marriage with a touch of humor and a heavy dose of glamour, backed by stellar costume design and a retro atmosphere that perfectly captured each era.
The series’ official synopsis highlighted this compelling narrative:
“An anthology series that follows three women in different decades all living in the same house, as they deal with infidelity and betrayals in their marriages.”
Season 2, which aired in June 2021, took a slightly different approach. It focused on Alma Fillcot, portrayed by Allison Tolman, whose descent into chaos wasn’t spurred by her husband’s actions but rather a deadly feud with Rita Castillo, played by Lana Parrilla. Despite diverging from the first season's focus on spousal betrayal, Season 2 maintained the show's central theme: when pushed to their limits, women might find murder to be the only viable escape.
Despite the show's popularity and critical acclaim—including an 8.
3 rating on IMDb and an 89% Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes—Paramount+ decided to pull the plug. The cancellation announcement was a blow to the show's dedicated fanbase, especially given that Season 3 was on the brink of production. The network released a brief statement, saying:
“Paramount+ has made the difficult decision not to move forward with season 3 of *Why Women Kill*. We would like to thank our partners at CBS Studios and Imagine Television Studios, the amazing creator and showrunner Marc Cherry, and the incredible writers, cast, and crew for two memorable seasons.
”
The abrupt decision, without any detailed explanation, has led to rampant speculation. Rumors suggest that financial constraints might have played a role, but Paramount+ has not confirmed this. For fans, the cancellation feels especially baffling given the show's commercial success and the critical praise it garnered.
Creator Marc Cherry, renowned for his work on *Desperate Housewives* and *Devious Maids*, was praised for his ability to craft complex, non-linear narratives.
His approach in *Why Women Kill*—particularly in Season 1—masterfully depicted how the struggles of women transcend time, with each character’s story feeling both distinct and universally relatable.
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
Next page
