"I can’t blame my mother for what she did, but I can’t forgive her, either." — Brianna Fraser, Outlander
Outlander, the beloved historical drama series, has its share of fan-favorite characters and those that viewers love to hate. One character who has sparked significant controversy among fans is Brianna Fraser. But what is it about Brianna that stirs such strong emotions? Let's delve into the reasons why some Outlander fans have such a strong dislike for her character.
Background on Brianna Fraser
Brianna Fraser, portrayed by Sophie Skelton, is the daughter of the series' protagonists, Claire and Jamie Fraser. Introduced in the second season, Brianna's character has been a focal point of many critical storylines. Despite her integral role, she has not escaped criticism from the show's passionate fanbase.
Entitlement and Bratty Behavior
One of the most cited reasons for disliking Brianna is her perceived entitlement and bratty demeanor.
Fans have expressed frustration over scenes where Brianna's actions come across as immature and irrational. For instance, a scene where she throws a potato at her husband Roger's head over a minor inconvenience has been highlighted as an example of her childish behavior.
The Fraser Temper: Temperament or Bad Attitude?
Brianna is often described as having inherited the "Fraser temper" from her father, Jamie. However, many fans argue that her outbursts are less about a fiery spirit and more about a bad attitude.
Incidents where she reacts explosively, such as an altercation with Mrs. Bugg, have led viewers to question whether her temper is a justifiable trait or simply poor character development.
Comparison to Claire Fraser
Some fans believe that Brianna's temperament is more akin to her mother, Claire, rather than her father. Claire's quick temper and tendency to lash out physically are traits that some fans see reflected in Brianna.
This comparison often leads to debates about whether Brianna's behavior is a result of nature or nurture, and why it seems to be less accepted than similar traits in Claire.
Underdeveloped Character Arc
Another point of contention is the inconsistency in Brianna's character development. While main characters like Jamie and Claire are given extensive, nuanced story arcs, Brianna's growth often feels rushed or incomplete. This has left many fans feeling disconnected from her character and less invested in her storylines.
Relationship Dynamics with Roger
Brianna's relationship with Roger MacKenzie has also been a significant source of criticism. Fans have been divided over their dynamic, with some feeling that Brianna's treatment of Roger is unfair and harsh. This tension in their relationship adds another layer of complexity to fans' perceptions of Brianna, often painting her in a negative light.
Gratuitous Violence and Shock Value
Outlander has been criticized for its use of gratuitous violence, particularly towards female characters. Brianna's storyline includes some of these controversial scenes, which many fans feel are included more for shock value than meaningful narrative progression. This has contributed to the negative reception of her character and raised questions about the show's handling of sensitive topics.
Fan Loyalty and Mixed Reactions
Despite the criticisms, Brianna has her defenders. Some fans appreciate her strength and resilience, arguing that her flaws make her more relatable and human.
The divided opinions on Brianna highlight the complexity of her character and the passionate engagement of the Outlander fanbase.
What are your thoughts on Brianna Fraser? Do you love her, hate her, or find yourself somewhere in between? Share your opinions in the comments below and join the discussion!
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
Next page
